Book Your Stay

Best Ice Cream in Old Forge

Best Ice Cream in Old Forge

We All Scream For…

Nothing Says Summer like a scoop of Ice Cream! Doesn’t ice cream make everything better – even an awesome day around Old Forge! Here are our top picks for the best Ice Cream in the Old Forge Area!

Dining at Pied Piper is like stepping back in time to the 50s! This old-fashioned ice cream stand features three assorted flavors of soft-serve ice cream and 20 flavors of hard ice cream. Milkshakes are a favorite and so are floats and banana splits. Relax at a picnic table and watch folks go down the water slides, walk to the edge of Old Forge Pond and sit by the water on a bench, or walk to the dam while you enjoy your ice cream.

With the slogan, “Benny’s! Who needs Jerry!” Benny’s Ice Cream will fulfill your cold, creamy desires. Benny’s serves the finest custard around which means you’ll get the creamiest and richest flavor ice cream, they blend egg and a higher milk-fat. All ingredients of this delectable delight are from New York State Dairies and distributors in the Central New York region. Complementary sprinkles will top off your custard nicely!

Served inside Enchanted Forest Water Safari at two locations, Dippin’ Dots is sure to be a crowd pleaser! Next to the Oasis Cafe in the middle of the park and next to the circus area and dry rides, Ice Cream of the Future® awaits you and your crew! Made of tiny ice cream ‘dots,’ flavors are blended to create offerings such as Banana Split, Cookies ‘N Cream, Rainbow Ice, Caramel Brownie Sundae and many more. Dippin’ Dots® ice cream is the coldest ice cream around…what an excellent treat on a hot, sunny day!

Adirondack Pizzeria & Arcade – This Old Forge staple proudly serves soft serve ice cream and Mercer’s hard ice cream, made locally in Upstate NY. You can enjoy hand-spun milkshakes and blizzards, banana splits, hot fudge brownie delight, old-fashioned sodas and floats, and ice cream sundaes all with endless possibilities of toppings! Take home Mercer’s hard ice cream too, pints are available for purchase!

Book NowStay ‘N Play
Book NOW for Summer!
Save with Stay 'N Play!
Click here!
Old Forge Camping